Moretown Stories and Legends

BREIF HISTORY OF MORETOWN, VERMONT

for the Celebration of Moretown's Heritage and St. Patrick's Church Centennial 1982

compiled by Mary Reagan

General History

The town of Moretown was chartered on June 7, 1763, said charter being granted by King George the Third through Governor Benning Wentworth of New Hampshire. Rental was imposed of one ear of Indian corn per year for ten years, payable on December 25.


The original grant contained six square miles of land and had 23,040 acres. It is a mountainous area, well watered by numerous streams and springs. The Mad River is the principal water course. This river originates in Granville Gulf at a spot some old-timers know as "Puddle-Dock." The Mad River runs through the entire length of the town and empties into the Winooski River south of the power plant near Middlesex. Another sizable stream is Jones Brook, with its tributaries, the Ward and Herring Brooks. Old records also state that Moretown once boasted several good mineral springs.


The actual settlement of the town commenced about 1790. In that year Ebenezer Haseltine came from Lunenburgh, Massachusetts, and began to clear a farm on the Winooski River about one and one-half miles from the Duxbury town line. He found that he had a neighbor, Seth Munson, who had preceded him. This area, which is on route 2, is known as the Rock Bridge section of Moretown. Prior to these settlers, the Indians evidently used this area because excavations have unearthed arrowheads and stone hatchets. In addition, the Winooski River was one of the routes used by the St. Francis Indians when raiding settlements in southern Vermont and central Massachusetts. When the Indians were on their way to burn Royalton, they camped on the meadow owned by Ebenezer Haseltine. According to some records, the land near the Palisades, which were destroyed by the 1927 flood, was part of the possessions of Ira Allen, a prominent Vermonter.


Some of the earliest settlers in Moretown were the Haseltines, the Munsons, the Holts, the Howeses, the Lovejoys, the Evans, the Fosters, the Childs, the Beldings, the Heaths, the Bulkeleys, the Kinsleys, the Hayletts, and the Lees. Descendants of many of these families still reside here.


Moretown has the distinction of being the only town in the United States by that name. It is said that when Washington County was being formed and maps were being made of the townships, a large parcel of land was found to be left over, so it was called "More-town." Because of its mountainous geography, the town is divided into several neighborhoods, which prevented building any large village within its borders. Moretown Village is in the southwest corner of the town. The so-called Rock Bridge district is in the northwestern part. Jones Brook is in the northeastern area, and Cox Brook is in the southeastern part of town. Other areas are known as Cobb Hill, Moretown Common, South Hill, Lynch Hill, and the Taplin and Flanagan areas.


Town records of March 9, 1792, show that Joseph and Ebenezer Haseltine, Seth Munson, and David Parcher petitioned Justice of the Peace Richard Holden of Waterbury to call a meeting of the voters of Moretown. This first town meeting was held at the home of Joseph Haseltine for the purpose of electing officers of the town. Later on, town meetings were held on Moretown Common when the center of population seemed to have moved into that area. In 1832 it was voted to move the town meetings to the "Hollow," which is the present Moretown Village. The Town Hall was started by subscription about that time and is still in use.


The Common area played an important part in local history, with a church, a school, and the community ovens, where it was the custom of the women to gather one day a week to do their baking. As houses improved, the baking was done at home in ovens near the fireplace. Before it was remodeled, the house to the right of the present Post Office contained one such oven. This is the oldest house in the village. The oldest house in town was the Haseltine house in the Rock Bridge area near the Duxbury town line. This house is no longer there. I believe it was moved out of town and has been restored.


Some of the first settlers used a stump-mill for grinding corn. This mill was made by burning a large cavity in the top of a solid stump. Corn was placed in the cavity and was ground to meal by pounding it with a huge pestle. Many of the farmers, however, took their corn down the Winooski River to a mill in Burlington. They carried both skiff and corn past Bolton Falls, apparently preferring the easier watercourse to the rough and rugged road to Montpelier.


The population of the town in 1791 was 24. By 1860 it reached a peak of 1410. In 1925 it had decreased to 930. Gradually over the years it has increased again, and by 1980 the population was 1221. The town has kept growing slowly with retired people and young families moving in. Many of the younger people commute to other towns to their employment. The first birth in town was probably Polly Phemia Munson. The first death was Paul Knapp, killed by a falling tree.


Floods


In the very early 1800s an unusual cloudburst occurred in the Jones Brook area, It lasted about half an hour but caused severe devastation. It poured through homes, swept away shanties, trees, logs, lumber, and everything else in its path. Oren Clark, who owned a sawmill about one mile from the mouth of the stream, reported hearing a deafening roar. He looked up and saw a wild sea of floodwood and turbid water with a wall-like front ten feet high rolling down upon himself and an employee. Both Mr. Clark and his hired man were swept into the water. Mr. Clark was able to save himself by grasping a tree branch, but the hired man was drowned.


In both 1830 and 1869 severe freshets occurred, doing much damage, especially along the Mad River. But the greatest damage from the river occurred in the 1927 flood of November 3 and 4. Both the Mad River and the Winooski River rose to unheard of heights in a matter of twenty-four hours, flooding everything in their paths. Damage in Moretown was extensive. Five lives were lost as well as many farm animals and livestock. In addition, thirty-eight bridges were swept away, and many roads were completely destroyed. Houses, barns, and other buildings were washed downstream, and nearly all remaining structures were flooded with several feet of water. One dam was carried away, and thousands of feet of lumber and acres of meadow land were lost. In the Rock Bridge district, the Palisades, a lovely scenic spot on the Winooski River, was completely destroyed. A more detailed description of the 1927 flood can be found in a booklet compiled by Lydia (joss Billings for the Moretown Bicentennial of 1963.


Again much damage occurred during the 1938 hurricane. Water covered the floor of the bridge just south of the village, washing out one end. Trees were blown down, roads washed out, much lumber lost, and homes and farmland flooded. Other lesser damage has occurred through the years. The Mad River, usually a quite placid stream, is well named because it can rise to destructive heights in a matter of a few hours after heavy rains or when the ice breaks up in the spring. Residents have learned to keep a careful watch on this river.

Industries and Services


During the mid-nineteenth century there were a great number of businesses and services in the various sections of town.


In Moretown Village there was a harness shop, a tin shop, a carriage shop, a livery stable, a blacksmith shop, a general store, a hardware store, a dressmaker, a hotel, a cider mill, a gristmill, lumber and clapboard mills, a wheelwright, a creamery, and a distillery for making whiskey. This distillery was owned by a Mr. Stevens in 1882, and it was noted in old records that his death two years later was "a great loss to the town." There were also two doctors, a lawyer, an undertaker, a school, a church, and a post office.


The lumber industry was an important part of Moretown's economy. Two or three sawmills, a buttertub factory, and a cider mill were located on Jones Brook. A lumber mill and a clapboard mill were located on the Winooski River opposite Middlesex.


A box shop and gristmill owned by Hiram 0. Ward in the village was the forerunner of the Ward Lumber Company. These mills employed a majority of the families residing in the village and some from surrounding areas. Owning thousands of acres of forest land, the company also provided work for loggers and truckers. In the 1920s the Ward Lumber Company began an extensive reforestation program which continued until the property was sold. This practice replenished the forest and protected the water tables. During school vacations, students were hired to prune the young trees or to work at other simple tasks around the mills. Many young people earned their spending money or saved toward further education in this way.


These mills were subject to much damage through the years. The flood of 1927 caused extensive damage to all the mills and the loss of thousands of feet of lumber. In 1936 the lower mill was completely destroyed by fire, the work of an arsonist. It was rebuilt shortly afterward. In 1955 another fire destroyed the upper mill at the south end of the village. A modern facility was built just across the road from the original site. This building was later sold and renovated into the present Mill Restaurant. Still another fire in 1960 again destroyed the lower
mill. After this latest disaster, the mill operations, except for the clapboard mill, which is the only remaining mill still in operation in the village, were moved to Waterbury, Vermont, in 1960. Operations continued there until 1969 when the mills in Waterbury and 27,000 acres of land in fourteen towns were sold to Laird Properties.

Farming was the main source of livelihood through the 1800s and the early to mid 1900s. The farms were small, but except for staples like sugar and flour, nearly all food, including meat, was raised on the farm. The women were hardy, doing all the baking, sewing, and often helping out in the fields and with other farm chores. Some lumbering and maple sugarmaking added to the farmers' incomes. Now there are only five or six operating farms in town. These farms are much larger, with a big dairy herd and modern barns, farm machinery, and other equipment.

There were at least three power plants in Moretown. One was located in so-called Lovers' Lane and was destroyed in the 1927 flood. Two others were located on the Moretown-Middlesex Road. One of these was located near the old Casey Bridge and was managed for a great many years by Walter Brooks, who is now eighty-nine years old. Although it ceased operation sometime in the 1950s, the dam is still there and is owned by two young Moretown men, Rick Hungerford and Chris Dryland, who have applied for permits to rebuild the plant and produce power to sell to other electric companies. The third power plant was built in 1896 at Middlesex Gorge and is still in operation. These plants furnished electricity for many surrounding towns and were a good source of tax revenue for Moretown.


The creamery, located in the village, was in operation until the mid 1930s and was managed by Birney Griffith. Many farmers sold their milk and cream there. Butter was made and sold at this creamery, and also fresh cream could be obtained there. A spring on this property furnished the creamery with ice-cold water. The foundation of this building is still in existence.


The Eastern Magnesia Talc Company, which opened in 1911, was an important industry in the Rock Bridge area. About thirty-five people were employed there, coming from Duxbury and Waterbury as well as Moretown. The talc was used for powder, insecticides, and paints. The company also owned two other mines in other parts of Vermont. In 1961, when talc was being converted to liquid instead of powder, this plant was closed because the source of the talc, being about one mile from the mill, caused the mill operation to become too expensive. This was a great loss to that area of the town.


The first physician was Dr. Stephen Pierce. He was followed by Dr. Lester Kinsley, who settled here in 1827. Dr. Kinsley also served as postmaster, town representative, and town clerk, holding that position until his death in 1881. Dr. James Haylett came to Moretown in 1889. He also represented the town in the legislature and was town clerk for many years.


The first town clerk was Seth Munson, elected in 1792. The town clerk's office was usually a room in the home of the current officer. In 1956 a town clerk's office was built. Within a few years, more space was needed to store increasing amounts of records and to afford a meeting place for the town officers, so in 1975 a sizable addition was built. The present town clerk, Mrs. Bernadette Ferris, has held that position for the past twenty-six years.


The first U.S. Post Office in Moretown was established in 1826, and Ira Carpenter was the first postmaster. Prior to this date, starting in 1818, postal service through the Mad River Valley was by stagecoach from Rochester to Montpelier twice a week. There was also mail service via a stage line from North Fayston to Moretown and from Waitsfield to Moretown and Middlesex. At first, the postmasters worked out of their homes. Later on, space in the Wilcox General Store and the Ward Lumber Company General Store was used. A considerable amount of growth has occurred in the last twenty years: there were about 60 post office boxes rented in 1963, and there are now 124 rentals. The rural route was established in 1903 and has been extended many times. There were 200 rural route boxes in 1963, and there are now 387 boxes. Milo White was mail carrier for thirty-two years, retiring in 1960. Harold Perry is the present rural carrier, and Gertrude Murphy is the present postmaster.


In 1873 Lilla Bulkeley Haylett, wife of Dr. James Haylett and a member of the Moretown Dramatic Club, began a fund to start a library in the village. The sum of $26.00, netted from a play, was left to accrue interest, and by 1904 had grown to $89.70. An association was formed, and an additional sum of money was raised by popular subscription. This money, along with a $100 gift of books from the state, was the start of the library.


From 1904 to 1915 there were two separate sections in the library. One was known as the Free Library where books were loaned at no cost. The other was the Public Library where patrons paid yearly dues. Located in the old Ward Lumber Company office building, the library functioned until 1919 when it was closed because of financial problems and inadequate quarters. By this time the Public Library had sold out to the Free Library. However, over a period of five years, Mrs. Haylett wrote to friends, relatives, and former town residents who had moved to other parts of the country, and she stressed the need for funds. The response was gratifying, and the present building was purchased in 1924 for the sum of $450. Extensive renovations were made, and it reopened in 1925. It was then renamed The Moretown Memorial Library because most of the donations were made in memory of loved ones and friends. The present librarian, Mrs. Norma Kingsbury, has held that position for several years.


The Moretown Volunteer Fire Department was first organized in 1957. At that time the town voted to buy an old Jeep four-wheel drive truck. The first firehouse was a small shop owned by Bill Blair and located between what is now the town clerk's office and the Grandfield house. In 1958 the firemen raised money to buy an old Maxim fire truck for $400. At the first recorded meeting in May 1958 the officers were elected: Richard Hayes, fire chief; George Hurdle, assistant chief; Royce Farnsworth, finance officer; Carroll Williams, secretary; Douglas Reagan, Norman Grandfield, and Adrian Ferris, ways and means. Other charter members were Glenn Ferris, Raymond Farnsworth, Meridan Nelson, Oswell Goss, Bernard Reagan, Robert Horsman, Carlos Nelson, and Eugene Grandfield, making a total of fifteen members. The department now has twenty-five members. The present fire chief is Randy Grandfield.


In 1959 the town voted to buy a new fire truck, a Ford Pumper. An addition was built onto the shop to house the new truck, but there was still no room to do the maintenance work. So in 1962 the town voted to build a new firehouse on land that had been donated by the Ward Lumber Company. The new building was painted by the firemen. In 1966 the department acquired a 1966 Mack truck, which they converted to a water tanker. The town bought a new Ford pumper in 1980, and the department also has a four-wheel drive van for rescue work.


The firemen have had many fundraising projects through the years, such as suppers, dances, bingo, auctions, birthday calendars, and money drops. They have bought a great deal of fire equipment with these funds at no cost to the town. The department has a special phone line on which they can be notified of fires. They also have two-way radios in three of the vehicles, plus small scanners for the men to carry. The men spend many hours cleaning chimneys, doing controlled burning, hauling water, filling swimming pools, and so on. Moretown is very fortunate to have a well-equipped fire department and the services of these dedicated volunteers.


Churches

When a group of people settle an area, there usually is a compelling need to establish a place of worship. The early settlers of Moretown apparently felt this need, for in the early 1800s a Congregational Church was organized in town. Meetings were first held in a log schoolhouse and later in the Town Hall in the village. Between 1836 and 1840 the membership became so small that it merged with the Congregational Church in South Duxbury.


The first minister in town was probably Amasa Cole, who lived near Middlesex. He gathered people together on Moretown Common. A preacher, Joshua Luce, who came from Pittsfield, Massachusetts, settled in Moretown in 1809. He started a Methodist class within the so-called Barre Circuit. Several other ministers held services in various homes or locations until the first Methodist Church was built on Moretown Common in 1832. A new church building was built in the village in 1853, and this church still serves the town under the Troy Conference Jurisdiction.

In 1922 several of the faithful stewards of the church decided the building was showing the ravages of too many years of hard use. Not just church sessions, but Sunday School, Epworth League meetings, Christmas tree celebrations, and other group meetings were held there. That summer, meetings were held in the Town Hall so that renovations could be completed. All new pews were installed as well as new areas for the choir and chancel. The unusual feature of the remodeling was that the lumber for the work was taken from the birch trees on the Ward Lumber Company land in the town. This lumber was sent to Burlington for the carpentry work and then installed.


In the past 100-plus years the church has been repaired, remodeled, and cared for many times. Heating and lighting have been modernized and the necessary repairs made. As recently as this year, 1982, the church has been renovated, largely by a group of young members doing much of the work themselves but with special monetary gifts of others. However, as continual care of painting and additions are made, the basic native foundation remains. The present pastor, Rev. Herman Benjamin, who also serves the Middlesex Methodist Church, lives with his wife and children in Moretown in the parsonage.

The first Catholic Church in Moretown was built in 1857 and was located on South Hill in the area of the Catholic cemetery where the cross now stands. The original steps to the church can still be seen. Land was deeded to the Roman Catholic Society by J. P. Miller and Peter Lee of Montpelier in 1841. A Captain Charles McCarty, who owned the house where Mrs. D. Strickland now lives, and other prominent residents of South Hill gave money to have a church built and a cemetery established on that land. Prior to the building of that church, Father O'Callaghan, the first resident priest in the state of Vermont, offered the first mass in Moretown on a flat rock in the pasture of the former Reagan Farm on South Hill. A marker to commemorate this event was placed there in the 1920s.



 

Most of the early Catholic families who settled in Moretown were Irish immigrants who came to this country in the mid 1800s. They purchased land on South Hill, or "Paddy Hill" as it was sometimes called. Some of the early settlers were the Murrays, the Hogans, the Cavys, the Farrals, the Devines, the Flanagans, the Murphys, the McCartys, the Lees, the Costellos, the Caseys, the Donahues, the Keltys, the Hassetts, the Lynches, and the Kerins. Descendants of these families can still be found here and in nearby towns. Children of these families attended a school on South Hill just across from the Gove Farm turn. Parts of the foundation of the school can still be found there.


The northeast corner of the cemetery where the church was located was the burial place of the Irish Catholic workers on the Central Vermont Railroad, which was being built at that time. Many of these workers died in the diphtheria epidemic of the 1870s and were placed in unmarked graves. It was said that the bodies were brought from Northfield in the night to be buried because of the fear of this dread disease.


Father O'Callaghan, along with later priests, Father Dollet, Father Druon, Father Duglue, and Father Galligan traveled through the state visiting the missions. Father Galligan came to Waterbury in 1869 and served there as well as in Moretown and Northfield.


In 1879 the Catholic Society began to think about building a new church in Moretown Village. Part of the property of Dr. Haylett was purchased by Francis Hassett, and he in turn deeded this property to Bishop DeGoesbriand of the Burlington Diocese. In 1822, through the efforts of Father Galligan, the present St. Patrick's Church was either built on this piece of property or the former church was moved from South Hill. The records are unclear at this point. Some say the original church burned down. Another story has it that parts of the church were moved. And others claim that the whole church was moved. At any rate, there was now a church in Moretown Village to serve the Catholic community of South Duxbury, Fayston, Waitsfield, and Warren. The beautiful stained glass windows of the church were given by, or in memory of, the original settlers. Many familiar family names can be found on these windows.


St. Patrick's became a permanent mission of the Waterbury parish, and mass was offered only once a month during the early 1900s. In the 1930s, with the help of priests from St. Michael's College assisting on Sundays, mass was offered every week. About 1954 Father Louis Logue became a curate at St. Andrew's in Waterbury, and he came to say mass nearly every Sunday. It was during this period that the Mad River Valley began to grow and become one of major ski areas in the Fast. There was a real need to expand the church facilities to serve the many newcomers. At first, Father Logue arranged to offer mass at the Base Box at Mad River Glen. Then, through his efforts, interest was aroused among other skiers and lodge owners, and plans were made to build a church in the Waitsfield area to serve these part-time residents and visitors as well as local people, It was evident that the Base Box and St. Patrick's could no longer accommodate them. So in 1965 Our Lady of the Snows Church was built in Waitsfield. This church, along with St. Patrick's, became a separate parish from Waterbury. Father Raymond Adams was the first pastor, followed by Father William Morgan, Father Donald Ravey, and the present pastor, Father Michael Madden, who came in 1977.


While Father Adams was pastor. St. Patrick's sanctuary was renovated. Gerald Grady did most of the work. The old altar was removed and replaced by the present one, which came from the Von Trapp family. It was once in their private chapel in the Trapp Family Lodge in Stowe, and Mr. and Mrs. Werner Von Trapp were married at this altar. When the family no longer had need of the altar, they offered it to any church that could use it, and Father Adams was glad to have it. Mr. Grady made the lectern and cross in the sanctuary.


While Father Morgan was pastor, it was found that the foundation of the church was unsafe. During the repair work in 1969, services were held in the Town Hall for many weeks. Later when services were resumed in the church, it was also found that the steeple was unsafe, and it was taken down. A new steeple was put in place in September 1977. The room behind the altar, called "Pat's Parlor" after Patricia Chant who did most of the work, was installed in the spring of 1977 for use as a library and for prayer meetings. Extensive renovations of St. Patrick's took place during the Holy Week of 1978. The entire interior, lighting, and altar screen were updated. A new furnace was installed in 1978. At the present time major repair work is being done on the foundation. When this repair work is completed, St. Patrick's will be in good condition to serve the Catholic community for many years.


It is important to note that the Catholic Church and the Methodist Church are situated only two buildings apart in Moretown Village. The Methodist Church is helping in the celebration of the Centennial. There is mutual respect and cooperation in every social and civic way as members of both churches pursue their faith in their chosen ways.


More Interesting Facts


In 1860 a sluice was built to pan gold and was located on a brook opposite the former home of Walter Brooks. Apparently this venture was not very successful.


In the early 1900s there was a military band in town with twenty-five or more members. A bandstand was located where the Girard de Carlo family now lives. Some of the members were Will Johnson. Carrol
Pierce, Pet Griffith, Frank and Roy Atkins, the Armstrong boys, and Charles Goss.


Moretown has furnished its quota to the military services. The list of those serving in the Revolution, the War of 1812, and the Mexican War of 1847 is not complete. More information is available for the Civil War and the Spanish-American War. World Wars 1 and 11 and the Korean and Vietnam conflicts have complete records available. A monument in front of the Methodist Church commemorates these men and women who served their country.


Moretown Village today has two restaurants, a snack bar, two stores, a ministore and coffee shop, a service garage, a post office, a real estate office, a tool shop, a laundromat, a greenhouse, a fire department, a clapboard mill, a consolidated school, a library, a Town Hall, a town clerk's office, and two churches. Two or three tourist homes offer accommodations all year, although they cater especially to skiers. Many new homes have been built as well as a multiunit apartment complex on the Moretown Common Road. Similar development has taken place in all other neighborhoods in the town. A housing complex for senior citizens is located near the Duxbury town line on Route 2.


Although Moretown, located on the outskirts of the Sugarbush and Mad River Glen ski areas, has not had the rapid growth of the other Valley towns, it has nevertheless grown slowly but steadily during the past fifteen years. Many young families have located here and are showing great interest in town affairs and in the heritage of the town. And after all, the most important resource of any town is its people.


Schools

Schools in Moretown have figured prominently in the development of the town. The first school was in the Rock Bridge area. Eight grades were in the same room and were taught by one teacher. In 1888 there were eleven school districts supporting twelve schools in Moretown, and the total enrollment was 226 pupils. The salary was $6.67 a week for a male teacher, and female teachers earned $4.31 a week. The total spent for all school purposes for that year was $1571.31. In addition to the school in Rock Bridge, there was one school located in each of the following districts: South Hill, Cox Brook on the Northfield Road, Jones Brook, the Taplin district near Middlesex, the Flanagan district on the Moretown-Middlesex Road, and the Village. There were two schools on Moretown Common. The school in the Village had two rooms and two teachers, and all the other schools had all eight grades in one room with one teacher. In the early years the teachers boarded in the homes of the families of the children they taught.


In spite of the efforts of the State Department of Education to keep and upgrade these local rural schools, the parents wanted for their children better opportunities, the competition of more children, separate grades, and so forth. They began to think about consolidating all the local schools into one larger school. And so in 1960 the Village school was remodeled and an addition built to incorporate all of Moretown's students.


Up to 1966 those children wishing to go on to high school had to furnish their own transportation to other towns because there was no secondary school in Moretown. However, the town did pay the tuition to the receiving high school. Then in 1966 Harwood Union High School opened after much effort and planning by the six area towns, including Moretown. The seventh and eighth grades were also moved to the new high school, and the six lower grades remained in the Village school. In recent years a kindergarten has been added to the Village school.


The 1981 elementary school enrollment was 121, there were 3 children in special education, and 92 children attended Harwood Union High School. This made a total school enrollment of 216.


I would like to thank the following people for their help in compiling this booklet: Aline Ward, Bernadette Ferris, Beatrice Eastman, Norma Kingsbury, Peggy Boyce, Evelyn Goss, Alice DeLong, Corky Griffith, and Mary Alice Edmonds. -M.R.


 
Page updated February 15, 2004